I’m not sure if political discourse has ever really existed during my life. Things seemed to start going downhill during the early Reagan years, may have slightly improved during the elder Bush administration, and then completely tanked during whitewatertravelmonicagate. The current Bush administration has only encouraged polarization, and both Democratic and Republican talking heads have wholeheartedly followed along (it is good business after all).
During my final year in college the biggest (mouthed) of them all came to Saint Olaf, my Alma Mater. Unsurprisingly the stereotypical far left college kids did all they could to shout her down and verbally attacked anyone that didn’t hate W enough (even though one of their main complaints against the president was first amendment rights weren’t being respected…hmm) and the college republicans in their khakis and polo shirts cheered wildly no matter the vileness Ms. Coulter’s statement. It was clear to me then that this was not an isolated incident. The lack of political civility has left college campuses and TV studios and has shown up on my front porch (if I had a front porch, and if it was a few blocks west of me).
I don’t remember a lot about my high school history class except that I answered too many questions, it was taught by a none with an unhealthy David Duchovny infatuation, and that I wished Henry Clay would resurrect himself for the sake of all of us. Who you may ask? He is best known as the great compromiser, bringing people with disparate opinions together for the greater good. He wasn’t perfect, and it could be argued that he only prolonged the inevitable (namely the civil war), but he at least gave the country extra time to possibly avoid war. At the very least, he helped opposing factions see the merit of the beliefs of each other.
Politics seems to have devolved from being about being right to winning. There is at least something noble about being right, even though there is much more gray than black or white in today’s world. Competition has reduced political discourse to a verbal spitball fight.
This all brings us to Friday night when the Critical Mass group, a bunch of mostly well meaning though blithely naive cyclists decided to block traffic, possibly play chicken with on-coming motorists, and then act shocked when they found out that breaking the law has unpleasant consequences.
Democracy is built on rights and obligations. Bikes have the same rights as cars, and the obligation to follow the same laws. People have the right to demonstrate, yell, act stupid, etc, but also the obligation to follow a direct order from the police.
This chaotic incident continues to chip away my hopes of a return to civility after the 2008 election. The basic knowledge of what makes a democracy works seems to be missing. I don’t know if its the schools’ fault, the fault of the media, or the fault of all of us. What I do know is that as the Republican National Convention approaches, things will get worse. Feel free to share any jokes about organized anarchists in the comment section.
More about the incident here: http://mnspeak.com/mnspeak/archive/post-3786.cfm
You tube videos galore here: http://youtube.com/watch?v=5nVMMeMq6xQ http://youtube.com/watch?v=g_PpgVUraQQ http://youtube.com/watch?v=4aUS4EQULBY